• Contact Us
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Donate
  • Login
Watchdog Uganda
  • Home
  • News
    • National
    • Politics
    • World News
    • Media Outreach Newswire
    • Africa News
    • Tourism
    • Community News
    • Luganda
    • Sports
      • Football
      • Motorsport
  • Op-Ed
    • #Out2Lunch
    • Conversations with
    • Politics
    • Relationships
  • Business
    • Agriculture
    • CEOs & Entrepreneurs,
    • Companies
    • Finance
    • Products
    • RealEstate
    • Technology
  • Entertainment
    • Lifestyle
  • People
    • Showbiz
      • Salon Mag
  • Special Report
    • Education
    • Voices
  • Reviews
    • Products
    • Events
    • Hotels
    • Restaurants
    • Places
  • WD-TV
  • Donate
  • China News
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • National
    • Politics
    • World News
    • Media Outreach Newswire
    • Africa News
    • Tourism
    • Community News
    • Luganda
    • Sports
      • Football
      • Motorsport
  • Op-Ed
    • #Out2Lunch
    • Conversations with
    • Politics
    • Relationships
  • Business
    • Agriculture
    • CEOs & Entrepreneurs,
    • Companies
    • Finance
    • Products
    • RealEstate
    • Technology
  • Entertainment
    • Lifestyle
  • People
    • Showbiz
      • Salon Mag
  • Special Report
    • Education
    • Voices
  • Reviews
    • Products
    • Events
    • Hotels
    • Restaurants
    • Places
  • WD-TV
  • Donate
  • China News
No Result
View All Result
Watchdog Uganda
No Result
View All Result

DR. IAN CLARKE:Justice Sebutinde’s Isolated Position

Watchdog Uganda by Watchdog Uganda
1 year ago
in Conversations with, Op-Ed
8 0
ShareTweetSendShare

Lady Justice Julia Sebutinde made a judgement at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) that outraged most people, not only in Uganda but in many parts of the world in a case brought by South Africa against Israel under the Genocide Convention. The International Court of Justice is under the jurisdiction of the United Nations, and adjudicates on matters between nations. For example, DRC brought a case that Uganda had looted and plundered Congo during its incursions, resulting in Uganda being ordered to pay $325,000,000 in compensation. There are fifteen judges, from various parts of the world, elected by the UN General Assembly and Security Council, who preside over the court. Justice Sebutinde was appointed in 2012 and reappointed for a second term in 2021. She is an experienced judge, having been a judge of the High Court of Uganda followed by a stint at the Special Court for Sierra Leonne from 2005 where she tried Charles Taylor.

She is no stranger to controversy, having carried out three public inquiries in Uganda, including one into corruption in the URA which was later challenged by the URA Inspector General and nullified. At the end of the trial of Charles Taylor his defense attorney was late in submission of the final summary, so Justice Sebutinde threw it out. The barrister then stormed out of the court and was later called for a disciplinary hearing. However, Justice Sebutinde refused to attend, and the hearing had to be dropped. Both the behavior of the attorney and that of the Judge were criticized by peers in the legal fraternity as setting a bad precedent.

Justince Sebutinde was also a judge in the case brought by Mauritius against the UK regarding the Chagos Islands in 2019. At the time of the de-colonisation of Mauritius Britain held on to the archipelago of the Chagos Islands and forcibly displaced the population of 2,000 people in order to establish a military base. The eminent Anglo-French Lawyer Phillipe Sands has written a book about this historic case called ‘The Last Colony’, in which he quotes Julia Sebutinde’s judgement which went against Britain.

Throughout her career Julia has never shown a need for approval and has stuck by her legal opinion, even if it is at odds with everyone else – as in this case in the ICJ in which she has disagreed with all the other judges. This genocide case has aroused the strongest of opinions worldwide since the scenes of destruction and human suffering are on our screens daily as we watch Israel pounding Gaza to rubble and killing tens of thousands of civilians, including women and children, who have nowhere to escape. In the eyes of the world, she is perceived as taking Israel’s side rather than using the opportunity to stop the slaughter.

The majority decision of the Court did not give a judgement on whether Israel is guilty of genocide, only that there is a case to answer, so they imposed provisional measures to ensure that acts of genocide are not continuing. Each judge does not necessarily reflect the views of their own government, but it was seen as significant that the American judge agreed with all the measures, thus sending a signal that American’s patience is wearing thin. Julia, on the other hand, did not reflect the position of the Ugandan government, but she was still seen as having betrayed Africa, particularly since the case was brought by another African country.
Her opinion was that the conflict is political and therefore needs a political settlement and should not fall under the Genocide Convention since acts of war are covered by International Humanitarian Law. Thus, in her opinion, the case is wrong from the outset and does not warrant the imposition of any provisional measures to prevent genocide.

Apparently, this case could take years to reach a definitive judgement on whether genocide has actually been committed, so there is not likely to be an answer soon. But for Justice Sebutinde this case is not about supporting one side or the other no matter how emotive the issue, it is about giving a legal opinion. She is simply doing her job as a judge, detached from the furore going on around her – but it must be a lonely position.


Do you have a story in your community or an opinion to share with us: Email us at editorial@watchdoguganda.com
Share2Tweet1SendShare

Related Posts

Museveni wants to secure and protect the telecom infrastructure
Op-Ed

How Opposition Instability Could Pave the Way for Museveni’s Victory in Uganda’s 2026 Elections

13th July 2025 at 11:18
Op-Ed

AKANSASIRA JUNIOR VICTOR: GEN. MUSEVENI’S GUIDANCE ON THE BALAALO ISSUE IS A GENERATIONAL CALL TO DISCIPLINE, PATRIOTISM, AND ORDER

10th July 2025 at 11:20
Dr. Ayub Mukisa (Ph.D.)
Conversations with

Dr. Ayub Mukisa: Does Karamoja need “wealth creation” or “value addition” on the already available wealth?

10th July 2025 at 10:07
Next Post
NUP president Robert Kyagulanyi, Mathias Mpuuga (inset) and Abed Bwanika

Abed Bwanika warns NUP "hooligans" from Kampala against interfering with Masaka politics 

  • Prostitution in Uganda- Courtesy Photo

    10 dangerous hotspots known for prostitutes in Kampala

    1131 shares
    Share 452 Tweet 283
  • Silent Billionaire Bosco Muwonge Buys Mukwano Arcade at UGX 250 Billion Cash Down

    53 shares
    Share 21 Tweet 13
  • Who is Bosco Muwonge, Uganda’s elusive real estate billionaire?

    39 shares
    Share 16 Tweet 10
  • LIST: New salary structure for civil servants starting July 2020 out; scientists, lecturers get juicy pay rise

    2290 shares
    Share 916 Tweet 573
  • Uganda’s Billionaires 2025: Once Again Sudhir Ruparelia Leads a Resilient Pack

    50 shares
    Share 20 Tweet 13
Facebook Twitter

Contact Information

Watchdog Uganda is a portal for solution journalism, trending news plus cutting edge commentaries in the fields of politics, security, business, tourism, entertainment, technology, agriculture, climate change, environment, public health et al. We also give preference to Ugandan community news and topical discussions. The portal also publishes community news and topical discussions.

Email: editorial@watchdoguganda.com
To Advertise:Click here

Latest News

Museveni wants to secure and protect the telecom infrastructure

How Opposition Instability Could Pave the Way for Museveni’s Victory in Uganda’s 2026 Elections

13th July 2025 at 11:18
Mashable is a global, multi-platform media and entertainment company For more queries and news contact us on this Email: info@mashablepartners.com

Check out

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Minister Muruli Mukasa

LIST: New salary structure for civil servants starting July 2020 out; scientists, lecturers get juicy pay rise

24th May 2020 at 10:45
Pregnant woman

Shock as 17-year old boy impregnates his two sisters during Covid-19 lockdown 

17th June 2020 at 08:17
Sudhir Ruparelia is the undisputed king of Kampala

Billionaire Sudhir’s wisdom on how to invest in real estate

0

How a boy’s destiny turned from cotton grower to communications guru

0
Museveni wants to secure and protect the telecom infrastructure

How Opposition Instability Could Pave the Way for Museveni’s Victory in Uganda’s 2026 Elections

13th July 2025 at 11:18

President Museveni lauds Chief Justice Owiny-Dollo for upholding truth and transforming the Judiciary 

12th July 2025 at 23:33

© 2025 Watchdog Uganda

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • National
    • Politics
    • World News
    • Media Outreach Newswire
    • Africa News
    • Tourism
    • Community News
    • Luganda
    • Sports
      • Football
      • Motorsport
  • Op-Ed
    • #Out2Lunch
    • Conversations with
    • Politics
    • Relationships
  • Business
    • Agriculture
    • CEOs & Entrepreneurs,
    • Companies
    • Finance
    • Products
    • RealEstate
    • Technology
  • Entertainment
    • Lifestyle
  • People
    • Showbiz
      • Salon Mag
  • Special Report
    • Education
    • Voices
  • Reviews
    • Products
    • Events
    • Hotels
    • Restaurants
    • Places
  • WD-TV
  • Donate
  • China News

© 2025 Watchdog Uganda